Reading a recipe and changing it
Reading and adapting

Reading a recipe and changing it: scaling, substitutions and altitude

A recipe read for its method before its quantities, scaled on the parts that scale, a substitution chosen by what the missing ingredient was doing, altitude handled from the federal figures, and the recipe rewritten in your words.

Start here Essentials

Take one recipe you already cook, read it for its method, halve it, and write down what it actually made and how long it actually took.

  1. Write its method in one sentence and its doneness test in another. If the test is a temperature and you have no thermometer yet, use a recipe without meat, poultry, fish or eggs for now (read the method first).
  2. Halve it, changing only the ingredient amounts and the pan. Keep the oven temperature; start checking early, because time follows the thickness of the food (what scales).
  3. Cook it and write down the yield you got and the time it took. Note your elevation if you are above about 2,000 feet (altitude).
  4. Put it in the repertoire sheet in your own words. Your pan, your yield, your time, your one change (rewriting the recipe).

Minimum time: about 15 minutes of reading and writing, plus the time the dish takes. Done when: a recipe you can cook is in the repertoire sheet in your own words, with your pan, your yield and your time, and the printed recipe is no longer the thing you reach for.

Read the method first Understand

A recipe is a method with one worked example. The method is the part that transfers: brown, then add liquid and simmer covered until tender. The ingredient list is one set of things it was done to, for one number of people, in one kitchen. Reading for the method is the skill two paid cooking programs build whole products around. Milk Street sells two courses on "the skills you need to cook quickly, confidently and easily without a recipe" (Milk Street Cooking School, Fundamentals), and Rouxbe's home-cook syllabus gives a unit of foundations to a "Map of Cooking" and the cooking methods (Rouxbe's Cook's Roadmap). At the other end of the market, a marketplace class that promises transferable methods teaches a single finished dish in each lecture (Cook Like a Pro, on Udemy). A recipe read only for its quantities is that class: one dish, which works until anything changes.

Four questions, in this order

AskWhat you are looking forWhere this manual teaches it
1. What is the method?The verbs. Is it dry heat (roast, sauté, broil), moist heat (simmer, poach, steam), or both (brown, then braise)? Write it in one sentence.The two families; the methods table
2. What is the doneness test?A temperature, a texture ("tender when pierced with a fork") or a look ("golden at the edges"). The time printed in the recipe is an estimate; the test decides.Done and safe; the safe temperatures table
3. What is the order?What has to be cut, measured or heated before the pan goes on, and what happens in what sequence once it does.Getting everything ready first
4. Only now: the quantities.Which amounts are the dish (the chicken, the beans) and which are seasoning (the salt, the spices, the acid). The first scale; the second scale and then get tasted.What scales; seasoning by weight

A recipe that gives a time and no doneness test is missing its most important line. For meat, poultry, fish, eggs and leftovers, write the test in yourself from the safe temperatures table: poultry 165 degrees F (73.9 C), ground meat 160 degrees F (71.1 C), whole cuts of beef, pork, veal and lamb 145 degrees F (62.8 C) with a 3-minute rest, fish 145 degrees F, by USDA's chart. The agency's position is that only a food thermometer settles whether those foods have reached a safe temperature. Even USDA's own chicken roasting timetable describes itself as "compiled from various resources" (FSIS, Chicken from Farm to Table), which is a good reason to treat every printed time as a time to start checking.

A recipe, read

Here is an ordinary recipe written for this manual, read with the four questions. The marks show what each line is doing.

Braised chicken thighs with white beans (serves 4) Pat 2 lb bone-in chicken thighs dry and season with 1 1/2 tsp kosher salt.Seasoning, and drying so the skin browns. "Kosher salt" with no brand: 1 1/2 tsp is about 4 to 4.5 g of Diamond Crystal or 7 to 7.5 g of Morton, by two test kitchens' weights. Weigh it. Brown skin side down in a Dutch oven over medium-high heat, 8 to 10 minutes.Method, part one: dry heat, browning. The time is an estimate; the test is a deep brown skin that releases from the pan. Remove; soften 1 chopped onion and 3 cloves garlic in the fat. Add 2 cans white beans, drained, and 1 1/2 cups stock. Return the chicken, cover, and simmer 35 to 40 minutes,Method, part two: moist heat, covered. One sentence: brown, then braise covered until done. until the thighs reach 165 F.Doneness test. Poultry, 165 degrees F by USDA's chart. This line is the one that decides. Finish with lemon juice and parsley.Acid at the end, tasted (acid).

Read that way, the recipe is one sentence of method (brown, then braise covered), one test (165 degrees F), one order (dry the chicken and chop the onion before the pot goes on), and quantities. The method would cook pork shoulder, chickpeas and greens, or a pot of white beans with sausage just as well, with a different test for each.

What scales and what does not

Halving or doubling a recipe is not multiplying every number on the page. Some things scale with the amount of food, and some do not. Getting the second list right is most of the job.

Part of the recipeScales?Why
Ingredient amounts (meat, vegetables, beans, grains, liquid for a soup)Yes, by the factorHalf the people, half the food.
SaltYes, by weightSeasoning by weight holds the same proportion at any size. A spoonful does not, unless it is the same brand (seasoning by weight).
Spices, chili, garlic, acidYes, then tasteScale them, then adjust by tasting; they are the amounts most worth checking. Preference
Oven temperature and burner settingNoThe heat is set by what the food needs at its surface, not by how much food there is.
Pan sizeChange it, by areaThe food should sit at the same depth. See pan size below.
Cooking timeNo; it follows thicknessTime depends on how far the heat has to travel into each piece and how deep the food sits, not on how many pieces there are.
Liquid that reduces in an open potPartlyEvaporation happens at the surface. Half the liquid in the same wide pot boils down faster.

The time rule is the one people get wrong. USDA's chicken timetable gives roasting times at 350 degrees F by the size of a piece: boneless breast halves of about 4 ounces, 20 to 30 minutes; legs or thighs of 4 to 8 ounces, 40 to 50 minutes; a whole 3 to 4 pound bird, 1 1/4 to 1 1/2 hours. A thigh is a thigh whether there are two on the tray or six, as long as they are not crowded. Halve a recipe for six thighs and the time is the same; halve a whole bird by roasting a smaller one and the time drops. Physical principle Check doneness early either way, because the printed time was written for someone else's oven and pieces.

Halving the awkward amounts

Kitchen measures halve cleanly once they are in tablespoons and teaspoons. NIST's kitchen equivalents put a teaspoon at 5 mL, a tablespoon at 15 mL and a cup at 240 mL (NIST, Metric Kitchen), so a tablespoon is 3 teaspoons and a cup is 16 tablespoons. The rest is arithmetic.

The recipe saysHalf is
1 cup1/2 cup (8 tablespoons)
3/4 cup6 tablespoons
2/3 cup5 tablespoons plus 1 teaspoon
1/2 cup1/4 cup (4 tablespoons)
1/3 cup2 tablespoons plus 2 teaspoons
1/4 cup2 tablespoons
1 tablespoon1 1/2 teaspoons
1 teaspoon1/2 teaspoon
1 eggBeat it, and use half by eye or by weight on a scale
1 can (15 oz) of beansAbout 7/8 cup drained, since a can is 1 3/4 cups drained (Nebraska Extension)

The scaling calculator scales a whole ingredient list by any factor, and lists the things it will not scale.

Pan size

When the amount of food changes, the pan should change so that the food sits at the same depth. What matters is the pan's area. For a rectangle, it is length times width; for a round pan or a skillet, it is about 3.14 times the radius squared. Physical principle

PanArea, square inches
13 by 9 inch baking dish117
11 by 7 inch baking dish77
9 by 9 inch pan81
8 by 8 inch pan64
9 inch roundAbout 64
10 inch skillet, across the topAbout 79
12 inch skillet, across the topAbout 113

Half of a 13 by 9 is about 58 square inches, so an 8 by 8 (64) holds a halved recipe at nearly the same depth. Double an 8 by 8 recipe and a 13 by 9 (117) is close to twice its area. A skillet is usually sold by its measurement across the top rim, and its flat base is smaller; measure your own base before you trust the table. Test it

On a tray, the rule from the oven chapter holds: food that roasts needs space between pieces, so a doubled tray recipe goes on two trays, not one crowded one (crowding). In a pot, a deeper pot of the same food takes longer to come to a simmer and reduces more slowly; a wider pot reduces faster.

Scaling up for a crowd

Doubling a weeknight recipe for guests follows the same rules. Cooking for twenty is a different job, with headcounts, quantities per person and a timeline, and Learn Event Planning covers it, including food safety for a buffet.

Yields: buying raw, serving cooked

A recipe lists meat by raw weight, and a plate is counted in cooked weight. The bridge between them is the cooking yield: the cooked weight as a percentage of the raw weight. USDA's Agricultural Research Service publishes it, and states its equation this way: "Yield (%) = 100 x (Wch / Wcr)" (USDA Table of Cooking Yields for Meat and Poultry, Release 2). Wcr is the raw weight recorded before cooking. Wch is the hot cooked weight, recorded after a brief rest the study specifies. The laboratory's own methods give a sense of what a yield measures: chicken drumsticks and thighs, for example, were roasted uncovered on a rack in a preheated 350 degrees F oven to 165 degrees F inside, and weighed after 30 minutes at room temperature.

These are rows from the laboratory's Excel file (Release 2, 2014, read row by row on 2026-11-05), as the file names the cut and the method.

CutMethodYield
Chicken, whole broiler-fryer, with skinBaked or roasted78 percent
Chicken breast, meat and skinBaked or roasted; poached or simmered72; 77 percent
Chicken thigh, meat and skinBaked or roasted; braised69; 68 percent
Chicken drumstick, meat and skinBaked or roasted76 percent
Turkey, whole, not enhanced, meat and skinRoasted71 percent
Ground beef crumbles, under 12 percent fat; 12 to 22; over 22Pan-fried69; 67; 62 percent
Ground beef patty, 12 to 22 percent fatPan-broiled73 percent
Beef chuck, under-blade pot roast, bonelessBraised64 percent
Beef bottom round roast; eye of round roastBaked or roasted84; 81 percent
Beef flankBroiled or grilled81 percent
Pork center loin chops, bone-inPan-fried76 percent
Pork tenderloin, lean and fatRoasted80 percent
Pork shoulder, arm picnicBraised74 percent
Ground pork crumbles, 10 to 27 percent fatPan-browned67 percent
Lamb, retail roastsBaked or roasted74 percent

Using a yield

Two directions, one division or one multiplication.

  • From raw to cooked: multiply. A pound (16 oz) of ground beef at 12 to 22 percent fat, pan-fried as crumbles at 67 percent, gives about 10 3/4 oz cooked: three and a half servings at the federal table's 3 ounces cooked.
  • From cooked to raw: divide. Four people at 3 oz cooked each is 12 oz cooked. Chicken thighs roasted at 69 percent need 12 divided by 0.69, about 17 1/2 oz raw, or a little over a pound. Six portions of pot roast at 3 oz is 18 oz cooked; chuck braised at 64 percent needs 18 divided by 0.64, about 28 oz raw, or 1 3/4 pounds.

A yield is an average from laboratory cooking. Your cut, your pan and how far you cook it change it: meat cooked well past its safe temperature loses more water than meat taken off at it. The "meat and skin" rows describe the meat and skin without the bone, so a bone-in package weighs more raw than the row assumes. Convention The scaling calculator applies these rows, and the servings turns cooked ounces into the table's servings.

Rice and beans

Grains and beans go the other way: they gain weight. Nebraska Extension puts 1 cup of uncooked rice at about 3 cups cooked (All About Cooking Rice), and a pound (2 cups) of dry beans at about 6 cups cooked. A second extension service publishes a lower figure for beans; the two are compared below. Grains and beans teach the cooking, and the grains and beans calculator does the arithmetic.

Go deeper

Bean yields: two extension services

Nebraska Extension: "One pound (2 cups) of dry edible beans yields about 6 cups of cooked beans" (How to Cook Dry Beans from Scratch). Kansas State Research and Extension: "1 cup dried beans makes 2-3 cups cooked", which at 2 cups to the pound is 4 to 6 cups per pound (How to Cook Dry Beans, 2009). The top of Kansas State's range meets Nebraska's figure; the bottom is a third lower. We give the range with both names and do not average it. Your own pot settles it: measure the cooked beans once and write the figure in the repertoire sheet.

Your own yield

The equation works on your food too. Weigh a package of meat raw, cook it, let it rest, and weigh it again. Divide cooked by raw and multiply by 100. If your thighs come out at 72 percent rather than 69, use 72 for your thighs in your oven.

Substitutions: what was the ingredient doing?

A missing ingredient is replaced by its job, not by its name. Before you reach for anything, ask what the missing ingredient was doing in the dish. Most ingredients in savory cooking do one of a few jobs.

The jobExamples in a recipeA substitute does the same job
SaltTable, kosher or sea salt; soy sauce; cheeseAnother salt, by weight, not by the spoon
AcidLemon, lime, vinegar, wine, tomatoesAnother acid, added a little at a time and tasted (acid)
Fat as the cooking mediumOil, butterAnother fat that suits the heat (which fat)
LiquidStock, water, wine, milkAnother liquid with the flavor made up elsewhere
BindingEgg in meatballs, patties or frittersThe extension chart's binding substitutes, below
The main ingredientChicken, pork, beans, a vegetableAnother of the same size and cut, with its own doneness test

Salt from a different box

Salt is the substitution most often done wrong, because a spoon of one salt is not a spoon of another. Milk Street's test kitchen gives the equivalence as "1 Teaspoon Table Salt = 1 Heaping Teaspoon Morton Coarse Kosher Salt = 2 Teaspoons Diamond Crystal Kosher Salt" (Milk Street, Worth Our Salt). By weight the swap is exact: the same grams of a different salt. The salt calculator converts a spoon of one brand to the same grams of another. Two test kitchens weigh the kosher brands slightly differently; seasoning by weight has both.

What can you substitute for an egg?

The University of Illinois Extension's chart groups egg substitutes by the job the egg was doing, per whole egg (Illinois Extension, Substitutions for Common Ingredients). The chart is written for baking. In savory cooking an egg is often a binder, in meatballs, patties and fritters, so the binding row is the one to try first. Test it

The egg's jobSubstitute, per whole egg, as the chart gives it
Binding1 tablespoon flax or chia seed plus 3 tablespoons water, left 5 minutes; or 1 package plain gelatin plus 2 tablespoons warm water
Moisture1/4 cup mashed banana, avocado, applesauce, pumpkin, sweet potato, mashed beans or silken tofu; or 2 tablespoons mayonnaise
General purpose2 egg whites, or 1/4 cup commercial egg substitute
Leavening1 1/2 tablespoons water, 1 1/2 tablespoons oil and 1 teaspoon baking powder (a baking job; see the Limits box)

The chart warns that "the flavor and texture may be slightly altered". A meatball bound with flax holds together differently from one bound with egg. Try it once on a small batch and write down what changed. The chart also gives milk and buttermilk substitutions, including instant nonfat dry milk made up with water; the substitutions table has the amounts.

A different protein changes the doneness test

Swapping the main ingredient is the substitution with a safety consequence, because the safe temperature belongs to the food, not to the recipe. A household that avoids pork, cooking a pork recipe with chicken, has changed its test from 145 degrees F with a 3-minute rest to 165 degrees F.

The recipe usesIts test, by USDA's chartYou use insteadThe new test
Pork chops or tenderloin145 degrees F, rest 3 minutesChicken breast or thighs165 degrees F
Ground beef160 degrees FGround turkey or chicken165 degrees F
Chicken165 degrees FFirm tofu or beansHot through; USDA's chart lists no minimum for tofu or beans as such (leftovers and casseroles are 165 degrees F)
Beef steak145 degrees F, rest 3 minutesA fish fillet145 degrees F

The time changes too, with the thickness of the new piece. A recipe for a thick pork chop, cooked with a thin chicken cutlet, will overcook the cutlet if you follow its time; follow the new food's test.

Limits

This chapter adapts cooking recipes. It does not adapt baked goods: in a cake, a bread or a cookie, the leavener, the gluten and a tested ratio make substitution and altitude a different subject, which Learn Baking Fundamentals takes up in its substitutions table. It does not adapt a recipe to meet a medical diet or an allergy; that is a clinician's or a registered dietitian's work. A substitution chosen here changes the dish, and the cook decides whether the result is good.

Go deeper

Why a baking substitution is a different problem

In a stew, an ingredient that does its job a little differently changes the taste, and you correct it by tasting. In a cake, the egg may be binding, leavening and adding moisture at once, and the flour, fat, sugar and leavener are in a ratio that was tested as a set. As we read it, that is why the Illinois chart separates the egg's jobs and gives leavening a row of its own. The proportions that make baking work are the subject of the baking manual, not this one.

Altitude

A recipe is written at one elevation, usually without saying which. Above a certain height, anything cooked in water takes longer, and the reason is physics, not the recipe. The figures below are from USDA's Food Safety and Inspection Service (FSIS, High Altitude Cooking).

  • Air pressure falls as you climb: 14.7 pounds per square inch at sea level, 12.3 at 5,000 feet and 10.2 at 10,000 feet, "a decrease of about 1/2 pound per 1,000 feet".
  • So water boils at a lower temperature. The boiling point drops "by just under 1 degree F" for each 500 feet. Water boils at 208 degrees F at 2,000 feet instead of 212, and at about 198 degrees F at 7,500 feet.
  • So moist-heat cooking takes longer. Simmering, braising and boiling "may take up to one-fourth more cooking time" at 5,000 feet, depending on the density and size of the food.
  • Turning up the heat does not help. "No matter how high the cooking temperature, water cannot exceed its own boiling point." A harder boil only drives the water off faster and dries the food out.
  • The air is drier above 2,500 feet, so moisture evaporates faster. Covering food while it cooks helps.
  • Oven temperatures are not affected. FSIS says to use the sea-level times and temperatures when oven-roasting meat and poultry.
ElevationWater boils atWhere the figure comes from
Sea level212 degrees F (100 C)FSIS
900 feetAbout 210 degrees FOur arithmetic on the FSIS rule
1,400 feetAbout 209 degrees FOur arithmetic on the FSIS rule
2,000 feet208 degrees FFSIS
5,000 feetAbout 203 degrees FOur arithmetic on the FSIS rule
6,200 feetAbout 200 degrees FOur arithmetic on the FSIS rule
7,500 feetAbout 198 degrees FFSIS

Most cookbooks treat 3,000 feet as high altitude, FSIS notes, though water already boils at 208 degrees F at 2,000. The agency lists fifteen states that are wholly or partly at high altitude: Alaska, Arizona, California, Colorado, Idaho, Montana, Nebraska, New Mexico, Nevada, Oregon, South Dakota, Texas, Utah, Washington and Wyoming. Your county or city website, a topographic map or a phone's maps app gives your own elevation.

What changes in the kitchen

  • Beans, grains, braises and soups take longer. Start checking at the recipe's time and expect to keep going. Test by texture, and write down the time it actually took.
  • Keep the lid on and watch the liquid. Drier air takes water faster; add a little hot water if a pot of beans or a braise runs low.
  • Rice may need its extra minutes. Nebraska Extension's method already has the fix: if rice is not tender or the liquid is not absorbed, replace the lid for 2 to 4 minutes more. Test it
  • Roasting is unchanged. The tray and the roast cook by sea-level times and temperatures, and finish on a thermometer as anywhere else.
  • Safe temperatures are unchanged. They are internal temperatures read on a thermometer, and the chart gives one set for every elevation. Calibrating a thermometer in boiling water is where altitude matters, because the water is cooler than 212 (calibrating the thermometer).

The altitude box on the timing calculator gives your boiling point and the extra moist-heat time from your elevation.

Limits

The altitude figures here are USDA's, and the in-between rows are our arithmetic on its rule. We publish no adjustment the agency does not. Baking at altitude changes leavening and liquid, and is worked out on Learn Baking Fundamentals' altitude page. Canning at any altitude is the National Center for Home Food Preservation's subject. A pressure cooker at altitude follows its maker's manual. Ask the authority

Rewriting the recipe in your own words

A recipe becomes yours when it is written for your kitchen: your pan, the number you feed, the yield it gave you, the time it took you, at your elevation. Writing it down is the step that turns one good dinner into one you can cook again without the original. Use this shape.

Name: what you call it at home Method: one sentence (brown, then braise covered until tender) Test: how you know it is done (165 F in the thickest thigh) Ready first: what is cut and measured before the pan goes on For: how many, scaled from the original Amounts: by weight where you can, salt in grams with the brand Pan: the one you actually used Made: the yield you got (cups, portions, cooked weight) Took: hands-on minutes, total minutes, and your elevation Next time: the one change to try

The repertoire sheet holds the dish, its method, the pan, the hands-on and total minutes, the servings it makes, who eats it and the one change. Keep the full card, with the method sentence, the test and the amounts, wherever you keep recipes. After a few cooks the card is shorter than the printed recipe, and closer to how you actually cook it.

When the dish goes wrong, the cook log holds what happened, and the log explains how one line there improves the next attempt.

See it: Walt halves a pot of beans at 6,200 feet See it

Fictional example

Walt Mbeki is a fictional person, and every fact about him here is invented for this manual. He is 71, cooks for himself and sometimes a neighbor, in a small kitchen with a two-burner hot plate and a countertop oven. He has a saucepan, a nonstick skillet, a thermometer and a scale. He lives at 6,200 feet and keeps his sodium down by his own choice, not on anyone's instruction.

His recipe, clipped from a newspaper, is for black beans to serve 8: 1 pound dry black beans, soaked; 1 onion; 3 cloves garlic; 1 teaspoon cumin; 8 cups water; 2 teaspoons kosher salt; "simmer 1 to 1 1/2 hours until tender".

Reading it. Method: simmer soaked beans with aromatics, covered, until tender. Test: tender all the way through when he bites one. Ready first: the soak, and the onion and garlic chopped.

Halving it. His saucepan holds a half batch. Half a pound of beans (1 cup), half an onion, 2 cloves of garlic (he rounds up), 1/2 teaspoon cumin, 4 cups water. The salt: "2 teaspoons kosher salt" names no brand. By weight it could be 5.6 to 10 grams (Diamond Crystal at America's Test Kitchen's 2.8 grams a teaspoon, or Morton at Milk Street's 5), so half could be 2.8 to 5 grams. He weighs 3 grams of his own salt, which by the 40 percent rule is about 1,200 mg of sodium in the pot, and plans to taste.

Known: the halved amounts, the pan, the elevation. His assumptions: water at his elevation boils at about 200 degrees F, by our arithmetic on the FSIS rule; the beans will take longer than the recipe's 1 to 1 1/2 hours, by FSIS's "up to one-fourth more" at 5,000 feet and possibly more at 6,200, where the agency gives no figure.

What happened. He used Nebraska Extension's hot soak: boil 2 to 3 minutes, then stand covered for up to 4 hours. He simmered with the lid on. At 1 1/2 hours the beans were still firm in the center. He added a cup of hot water at 1 3/4 hours, when the level dropped below the beans. They were tender at 2 hours 10 minutes. The pot gave 3 cups of beans, which matches Nebraska's 6 cups a pound and the top of Kansas State's 2 to 3 cups a cup. He tasted, and added nothing.

His card. "Black beans, half batch. Method: hot-soaked beans simmered covered with onion, garlic, cumin, until tender. Test: one bean tender through. For: 6 half-cup portions. Amounts: 1 cup dry beans, 1/2 onion, 2 cloves, 1/2 tsp cumin, 4 cups water plus about 1 cup more, 3 g salt. Pan: 3-quart saucepan, lid on. Made: 3 cups. Took: 15 minutes hands-on, 2 hours 10 minutes simmering, at 6,200 feet. Next time: start with 5 cups of water."

Open: whether 2 hours 10 minutes is typical for this bean at his elevation or depended on how old the beans were (his next few cooks, written down, settle it); whether 3 grams of salt suits him (his tasting, and his own choice); whether a pressure cooker would help (the maker's manual for any appliance he considers, at his elevation).

Practice: halve one recipe and rewrite it Practice

Minimum: read one recipe for its method and test, cook it halved once, and write it into the repertoire sheet with your yield and time. Time: 15 minutes of reading and writing, plus the cooking. Materials: a recipe you already cook, measuring spoons, a pan sized for half, and a thermometer if the dish has meat, poultry, fish or eggs.

  1. Mark the method, the test and the order. Write the method in one sentence and the test in another.
  2. Halve the amounts. Use the halving table for the awkward measures; turn the salt into grams with its brand.
  3. Choose the pan by area. Half the area, so the food sits at the same depth.
  4. Cook it, checking early. Same oven temperature; check doneness from about two-thirds of the printed time.
  5. Write down what it made and how long it took. Then put it in the repertoire sheet, with the one change for next time.
Go deeper

Measure your own yield. Weigh a package of raw meat, cook it to its safe temperature, let it rest, weigh it again, and work out the percentage with the federal equation. Compare it with the USDA row for that cut, and use your own figure from then on. Swap one ingredient by its job. Cook the same dish again with one substitution chosen from the job table, and write down what changed in the tasting sheet.

Your household Your household

Check your work Check your work

Criteria

  • Does the card state the method in one sentence and a doneness test in another?
  • For meat, poultry, fish or eggs, is the test a temperature from the federal chart?
  • Were only the ingredient amounts and the pan changed, with the oven temperature left alone?
  • Is the salt written in grams, with the brand?
  • Does the card record the yield you got and the time it took, and your elevation if you are high up?
  • If anything was substituted, does the card say what job the substitute was doing, and does the test match the new food?
  • Is the dish in the repertoire sheet with its one change?

Worked example

Walt's card passes every criterion. The method and test are one sentence each; the amounts are halved, with the salt in grams; the pan is the one he used; the yield (3 cups) and time (2 hours 10 minutes at 6,200 feet) are his, not the newspaper's; and the one change, more water at the start, comes from what actually happened. His card does not claim that 2 hours 10 minutes is the time for black beans at his elevation. It is one cook, and the next few will show whether it holds.

Common mistakes

  • Halving the cooking time with the ingredients. Time follows thickness, not quantity.
  • Keeping the big pan for a half recipe. The food spreads thin and overcooks, or a sauce boils away.
  • Swapping salt by the spoon. Swap by weight, or by Milk Street's equivalence if you have no scale.
  • Swapping the protein and keeping the old test. Chicken in a pork recipe is done at 165 degrees F, not 145.
  • Turning up the heat at altitude. Water does not get hotter than its boiling point; the pot only boils dry.
  • Adapting a baking recipe with this chapter's rules. Baking needs its own.

What is still unresolved

Whether the changed dish tastes right is settled by tasting, in the order tasting, fixing sets out. Your own cooking times at your elevation are settled by your own cooks, written down. Baking adaptations, and baking at altitude, are for the baking manual that is coming soon. Adapting a recipe for a medical diet is a clinician's work. Scaling for a crowd is Learn Event Planning's.

Knowledge check and scenario

A recipe for six chicken thighs roasts them 40 to 50 minutes. You halve it to three thighs. How long do they roast?
About the same, 40 to 50 minutes, because the time follows the size of each piece, not the number of pieces. USDA's timetable gives legs or thighs of 4 to 8 ounces 40 to 50 minutes at 350 degrees F. Check early, and finish on a thermometer at 165 degrees F.
A recipe says "2 teaspoons kosher salt" and you have table salt. How much do you use?
By Milk Street's equivalence, 1 teaspoon of table salt equals 2 teaspoons of Diamond Crystal kosher or 1 heaping teaspoon of Morton coarse kosher, so the answer depends on which kosher salt the writer used. Without the brand, start at the low end, about 1 teaspoon of table salt or less, and taste. Weighing removes the guess.
You need 12 ounces of cooked pot roast. How much raw chuck do you buy?
USDA's yield for boneless chuck under-blade pot roast, braised, is 64 percent. Divide: 12 divided by 0.64 is 18 3/4 ounces raw, a little under 1 1/4 pounds.
At 6,200 feet, a pot of beans is still hard after the recipe's time. Should you turn the burner up?
No. FSIS says water cannot exceed its own boiling point, which is about 200 degrees F at that height by its rule. A harder boil only drives off water. Keep the lid on, keep a gentle simmer, add hot water if the level drops, and keep cooking until the beans are tender.
(Go deeper) Nebraska Extension says a pound of dry beans makes about 6 cups. What does Kansas State say, and what does this manual do with the difference?
Kansas State says 1 cup dry makes 2 to 3 cups cooked, which is 4 to 6 cups a pound. The manual gives the range with both publishers named and does not average it; your own pot, measured once, settles it for you.
Rosa cooks for five. A sheet-pan recipe serves 4 and roasts at 425 degrees F for 25 minutes on one tray. What is the most reasonable way to scale it?
The time does not scale with the amount, and a crowded tray steams instead of browning. The extra quarter belongs on the second tray.
The amounts scale; the temperature and the time do not, because the pieces are the same size. Two trays keep the space between pieces. If the dish has chicken, it is done at 165 degrees F on a thermometer, whatever the clock says.
Feeding five from a recipe for four needs more food, not more heat. A hotter oven is more likely to burn the outside before the inside of each piece is done.

Checklist

Records your learning only; it is not a qualification.