Salt, fat and acid
The transferable parts

Salt, fat and acid: seasoning by weight, tasting as you go, and what each one does

Salt measured by weight with the brand named, the three times to add it, acid and fat as the two things a flat dish is usually missing, a fixed tasting routine, and the published sodium figures as numbers.

Start here Essentials

For a first pass, season one dish you were cooking anyway in measured amounts, taste it at each step, and write down which of salt, acid or fat changed it most. No scale yet: a measuring spoon and the brand name on the box will do.

  1. Taste before you add anything. Give the taste one word: flat, heavy, sharp or thin (taste first).
  2. Add salt in small measured amounts, tasting after each. Weigh it in grams, or use a level 1/4 teaspoon and write down the brand (why a teaspoon is not a quantity).
  3. Try acid on one spoonful. A few drops of lemon juice or vinegar in a spoonful, tasted beside the pot, tells you whether the whole pot needs it (acid).
  4. Write one row in the tasting sheet. The dish, the salt by brand and amount, and which addition changed it most.

Minimum time: one dinner you were cooking anyway, plus about 10 minutes of tasting. Done when: one row in the tasting sheet names the dish, the salt by brand in grams or spoons, and which of salt, acid or fat changed it most.

Taste first, then name what is missing Understand

A recipe gives amounts. It cannot give the amount your pot needs, because your tomatoes, your stock and your salt are not the recipe writer's. The step that closes that gap is tasting, and tasting is a skill with a routine, not a mood. The routine is short: taste, name what is wrong in one word, change one thing, taste again.

The naming is the part most cooks skip. "It needs something" is not a diagnosis. When a dish tastes flat, we work on the assumption that it is missing one of three things, salt, acid or fat, and the job is to say which before reaching for anything. Convention This is a working order that cooks teach, not a law of taste. Home-cook curricula treat it as a subject of its own: one online school gives basic seasoning its own unit, on "how salt affects food" and when to salt during cooking (Rouxbe's Cook's Roadmap syllabus), and another sells whole separate classes on acid, herbs, spices and savory depth (Milk Street's Fundamentals catalog). This chapter covers the same ground for free, one ingredient at a time.

The words and what they usually point to

What it tastes likeTry firstHow much at a timeWhat tells you it worked
Flat, dull, "needs something"SaltAbout 1 g (1/8 teaspoon of table salt is about 0.75 g)The other flavors get louder; you taste the tomato, not the salt
Heavy, rich, cloying, too sweetAcidA few drops of vinegar or a small squeeze of lemon, tried in one spoonful firstIt tastes lighter and the sweetness steps back
Sharp, harsh, thin, all edgesFatA teaspoon of butter or oil, stirred in off the heatIt tastes rounder and coats the mouth
Salted, bright and rich, but hollowSavory depthA spoon of tomato paste, a little grated hard cheese, a dash of soy sauceIt tastes meatier and longer
Too salty, too sour, bitter or burntNot an additionSee what is fixableSome can be diluted; no addition takes away burnt

Test the table on your own food before you trust it. Test it The three-cup test in Practice is the fastest way: three small cups from one pot, salt in one, acid in the second, fat in the third, tasted side by side.

Why the order is salt, then acid, then fat

We taste in that order for two practical reasons. First, salt is the gap a recipe is least able to close for you, because the right amount depends on your other ingredients and on the brand of salt in your box. Second, every addition is easier to put in than to take out, and salt and acid are the two that are hardest to take back. Adding salt first, in small steps, means each later decision is made on a dish that is already seasoned. Convention

How to taste

  • Use a clean spoon each time. You want to taste the pot, not the last spoonful.
  • Taste at the temperature you will serve it. Let a spoonful of soup cool for a few seconds before you judge it. Taste the same spoonful hot and again once it has cooled; many cooks find the two taste different. Test it
  • Taste the liquid and the solid. A stew's broth can be seasoned while the meat in it is bland, because salt takes time to move inward (the three times to salt).
  • Change one thing, then taste again. If you add salt and acid at once, you will not know which one fixed it, and the tasting sheet is only useful if you do.

The tasting sheet holds one row per dish: the dish, the salt in grams and the brand, the acid added, the fat added, and which one fixed it. After five or six rows you will see your own pattern, and that pattern is worth more than any general rule here. When the fault turns out to be cooking rather than seasoning, When it goes wrong continues the same order into undercooked, overcooked and the wrong method.

What salt does, and the three times to add it

Salt, in a recipe, means sodium chloride. It is about 40 percent sodium and 60 percent chloride by weight (Harvard's Nutrition Source). Seasoning is adjusting a dish's taste with salt and the other things in this chapter, as opposed to the main ingredients.

Salt does two jobs in cooking. It makes food taste of itself, which is the job tasting judges. It also behaves physically: it dissolves in whatever water is on the food's surface, and given time it moves inward. Physical principle Salt on the surface of raw vegetables draws water out of them, which you can see as beads of liquid on salted sliced zucchini or cucumber after a few minutes. That second job is why the time you add salt matters as much as the amount.

Before cooking

Salt added ahead has time to move into the food rather than sitting on the outside. This is why Twenty minutes in a skillet asks you to salt a chicken thigh by weight before it goes in the pan. Two cautions. Salted raw meat sits in the refrigerator, not on the counter; the agency's two-hour limit for food out of refrigeration applies to it like any raw meat (FSIS on the danger zone). And salt on a wet surface makes more liquid, which works against browning: dry the food again before it goes into a hot pan (what stops browning).

During cooking

Salt in the cooking liquid seasons everything that absorbs it: rice, beans, pasta, a braise. Nebraska Extension's rice method adds 1 teaspoon of salt, marked optional, to each cup of uncooked rice (All About Cooking Rice). Notice what that line does not say: which salt. A teaspoon of one brand of salt can weigh nearly twice what a teaspoon of another weighs, which is the subject of the next section. Where a published method gives salt by volume and no brand, we treat the figure as a ceiling, start lower, and taste.

One physical rule governs everything salted during cooking. Salt does not boil away. Physical principle When a sauce or a soup reduces by half, the water leaves and the salt stays, so the concentration doubles. A stock that tasted right at the start can taste far too salty after an hour uncovered. Salt a liquid lightly at the start, and do the real seasoning after it has reduced.

At the end

Salt added at the end corrects what tasting found, and salt sprinkled on the surface just before serving is tasted first, in crystals. A flaky salt such as Maldon is often used this way. Finishing salt is a Preference: it changes texture and the first taste, and it is still salt, counted in the same grams.

No agency or standards body publishes a seasoning amount for food, and we have not found a publisher for the common advice about salting pasta water to a particular strength. The salt calculator offers a salt percentage by weight of the food as a starting point. That percentage is this manual's convention and nothing more, and your tasting decides.

Go deeper

Brining and soaking

A brine is salted water that meat or poultry soaks in before cooking. Cooks brine for texture and seasoning. Two points from the agency are worth knowing before you try it. Soaking or brining "is a personal preference and serves no purpose for food safety" (FSIS, Washing Food). If you do it, keep the meat in the refrigerator while it soaks, pour the soak away afterward rather than reusing it, and clean and sanitize the container and the sink. The same page answers the opposite question: soaking a salty product to draw the salt out does little, because "very little salt is removed" by washing, rinsing or soaking. A salty ham is diluted on the plate, not in the sink.

Why a teaspoon is not a quantity

Salt crystals come in different shapes and sizes. Fine table salt packs tightly into a spoon. The hollow flakes of one kosher brand leave a lot of air. So a level teaspoon of one salt can weigh about twice a level teaspoon of another, and a recipe that says "1 tablespoon kosher salt" can mean very different amounts of salt depending on the box in the writer's kitchen. Product-specific

One test kitchen weighed nine salts and published the grams per teaspoon (Milk Street, Worth Our Salt). The four a home recipe most often means:

SaltGrams per teaspoonGrams per tablespoonSodium per teaspoon, at 40 percent
Table salt (Morton iodized)618about 2,400 mg
Fine sea salt515about 2,000 mg
Morton coarse kosher515about 2,000 mg
Diamond Crystal kosher39about 1,200 mg

Grams from Milk Street's weighing; the sodium column is our arithmetic, grams times 400 mg, from Harvard's figure that salt is about 40 percent sodium. A second test kitchen's weights for the two kosher brands differ slightly; both sets are under Go deeper below.

Read down the second column. Diamond Crystal at 3 g per teaspoon and table salt at 6 g mean that a teaspoon of table salt holds as much salt as two teaspoons of Diamond Crystal. Morton coarse kosher sits between them. Two test kitchens even mean different salts by the same word: Milk Street says it moved its recipes from Diamond Crystal to Morton because Morton makes accidental oversalting harder, while America's Test Kitchen names Diamond Crystal as its own go-to (America's Test Kitchen's kosher salt test). A reader following a recipe from either kitchen with the other kitchen's salt is off by a large margin before tasting even starts.

The default: grams, with the brand named

This manual works in grams, and writes the brand beside every number. Convention A gram of salt is a gram of salt whatever the crystal; the brand matters only when you measure by volume. Weighing also makes the tasting sheet useful across months: "8 g" means the same thing next year, while "2 teaspoons" means whatever box you happened to have.

When a recipe gives salt by volume and does not name the brand, use these steps.

  1. Look for the publisher's own note. Many test kitchens and cookbooks say which salt their recipes use, usually near the front of the book or on the site's about page.
  2. If you find none, assume the lighter salt: start with the weight a teaspoon of Diamond Crystal would give (3 g per teaspoon). Under-salting is fixed at the end in a minute; over-salting is not.
  3. Taste, and add the rest in steps of about a gram.
  4. Write the final grams and the brand in the recipe's margin and in the tasting sheet.

The salt calculator converts between ten salts by weight and by spoon, and prints the grams per teaspoon it used for both salts so you can check them.

Without a scale

A reader without a scale can still season accurately enough to learn from. Use measuring spoons, level them with the back of a knife, use one brand of salt and stick to it, and write the brand in the tasting sheet next to the spoons. Your own records then stay consistent with each other.

What this costs, plainly:

  • Recipes written for another salt need converting. Without the brand factor, a recipe written for Diamond Crystal and made with table salt gets about twice the intended salt. Convert with the calculator before measuring.
  • Spoons of coarse and flaky salt vary. A heaped spoon against a level one, or a spoon scooped from a packed box against one poured loosely, can differ noticeably. The figures in the table are one kitchen's measurement of level spoons, not a property of the salt.
  • Small amounts are coarse. The smallest spoon in most sets is 1/8 teaspoon, which is about 0.75 g of table salt and about 0.4 g of Diamond Crystal by the figures above. That is fine for tasting in steps.
  • Grams in recipes are out of reach. More recipes now give salt in grams. Without a scale you convert them back to spoons of your brand with the calculator, which brings back the brand uncertainty.

A kitchen scale is the one purchase this manual recommends for seasoning. Check the smallest step your scale displays: many read in 1 g steps, which is coarse for a pinch and fine for a pot. Product-specific If yours reads in whole grams, weigh the salt for the whole pot rather than per spoonful.

Go deeper

Two test kitchens, two sets of weights

Two named test kitchens have weighed the same salts and published different figures. They are both measurements, and we do not average them.

SaltMilk Street (2021), g per tspAmerica's Test Kitchen (2019), g per tspDifference
Table salt6 (Morton iodized)about 6, "regardless of the brand"agree
Morton coarse kosher54.8about 4 percent
Diamond Crystal kosher32.8about 7 percent

The gap between the two kitchens is small next to the gap between brands, which is a factor of about two in both sets. That is the reason this manual names the brand with every number: the brand decides the answer, and the kitchen changes it only in the second figure. The salt calculator uses Milk Street's figures, because they cover all nine salts it converts, and its assumptions line names America's Test Kitchen's figures beside them.

A cross-check: Harvard's Nutrition Source tabulates sodium per teaspoon as about 2,300 mg for fine iodized table salt, 1,920 mg for coarse kosher salt and 1,120 mg for Diamond Crystal. At 40 percent sodium, 1,920 mg and 1,120 mg correspond to 4.8 g and 2.8 g of salt, which are America's Test Kitchen's weights. Harvard's page also says sodium content varies widely among brands.

All nine salts Milk Street weighed

Saltg per teaspoong per tablespoon
Celtic sea salt, fine411
Diamond Crystal kosher39
Fleur de sel412
Himalayan pink, coarse718
Himalayan pink, fine618
Maldon sea salt410
Morton coarse kosher515
Morton iodized618
Sea salt, fine515

Some rows do not multiply cleanly by three from teaspoon to tablespoon (Himalayan coarse is 7 and 18). Each figure was weighed separately, and coarse crystals pack differently in a larger spoon. That is one more reason to weigh.

Acid

Acid, in seasoning, means a sour ingredient added for its taste: lemon or lime juice, vinegar, tomatoes, yogurt, wine, the brine from a jar of pickles. A dish that tastes heavy, rich, cloying or too sweet is often missing acid. A few drops make it taste lighter and make the other flavors easier to pick out. Test it Do not take that on trust: try it on a spoonful.

The spoonful test

Acid is easy to overdo and hard to take back, so test it before it goes into the pot.

  1. Take a spoonful of the finished dish.
  2. Add one or two drops of vinegar or lemon juice to the spoon.
  3. Taste it, then taste a plain spoonful from the pot.
  4. If the acid spoonful is better, add acid to the pot a little at a time, tasting between additions. If it is worse, the dish was not missing acid; try fat or savory depth.

Which acid, and when

The forms a household is likely to have, and what each adds besides sourness:

AcidWhat else it bringsTypical use
Lemon or lime juiceA fresh, fruity smellFinishing soups, beans, fish, vegetables, pan sauces
Wine, cider or rice vinegarMilder, with some fruitDressings, pan sauces, braises
White distilled vinegarSourness with little elseWhere you want acid and no other flavor
Canned or fresh tomatoesSweetness and savory depth along with acidStews, beans, braises
Plain yogurtFat and creaminessSpooned onto a finished dish off the heat

As a default, add acid near the end and taste. Long simmering changes how a fresh acid tastes, and a squeeze of lemon added at the table tastes different from the same squeeze stirred in an hour before. Test it The exception is a braise or a pot of beans where tomatoes or wine are part of the cooking liquid from the start; there the acid is an ingredient, and you still taste and correct at the end.

A pan sauce is the place where acid does the most work in the least time: liquid into a hot pan to lift what is stuck to it, reduced, then finished with acid and fat off the heat. Twenty minutes in a skillet teaches it. If you overshoot and a dish turns sour, the fixes, and their costs, are in what is fixable.

Fat

Fat in cooking does three jobs. It moves heat from the pan into the food, which What heat does covers. It gives texture: a sauce with butter stirred in coats a spoon and the mouth differently from one without. And it changes taste: a dish that tastes sharp, thin or harsh often tastes rounder with a little fat stirred in at the end. Test it

Fat as the third fix

In the tasting order, fat comes after salt and acid. Stir a teaspoon of butter or olive oil into a spoonful or a small cup first, as with acid, and compare. A teaspoon is also the serving size the current federal servings table uses for its Healthy Fats group: "1 tsp olive oil or butter" is one serving (Daily Servings by Calorie Level, 2025-2030). The table gives 4 1/2 servings a day at the 2,000 calorie level. We give the figure so you can count what you add, not as a target; Building a plate explains how the table works.

Which fat: what the current edition says

The Dietary Guidelines for Americans, 2025-2030, is the current federal edition. On cooking fats it says to "prioritize oils with essential fatty acids, such as olive oil," and that "other options can include butter or beef tallow" (Dietary Guidelines for Americans, 2025-2030). The same document sets a ceiling on saturated fat, the kind that is solid at room temperature in butter, tallow and other animal fats: "saturated fat consumption should not exceed 10% of total daily calories." At 2,000 calories a day, 10 percent is 200 calories. We report the figure as the edition states it; we do not assess anyone's diet against it.

For cooking, fat choice is also a heat question. A fat that smokes at the temperature you are cooking at tastes burnt, and one maker's compiled chart shows wide differences between oils. No standards body publishes such a chart, and the published charts disagree with each other, so Twenty minutes in a skillet uses the chart for order, not for exact thresholds.

What fat does to seasoning

A fat added at the end carries some flavors that water does not: a spoon of olive oil over beans, or butter in a pan sauce, adds its own taste and changes how the rest is perceived. Test it A fat added early, at the start of cooking, is where dried spices and aromatics such as onion and garlic are usually cooked first, so that they flavor the fat and the fat flavors the dish (herbs and spices). Convention

Savory depth, glutamate and MSG

Some dishes are salted, bright and rich, and still taste hollow. What they lack is often savory depth: the meaty, brothy taste that cooks also call umami. Much of it comes from glutamate, a form of the amino acid glutamic acid that is present free in some foods and released from protein when it breaks down.

Where it comes from

FDA names tomatoes and cheeses as foods with naturally occurring free glutamate, along with ingredients made from protein such as hydrolyzed vegetable protein, autolyzed yeast, yeast extract, soy extracts and protein isolate (FDA, Questions and Answers on MSG). In a home pantry that means tomato paste, a hard cheese grated into a sauce, and soy sauce, which is made from soybeans. These carry savory depth in small amounts. The pantry list has the short list the chapters use.

Add them the way you add salt: a little, then taste. Most of them also carry salt. Soy sauce and hard cheese especially add sodium along with depth, so taste after adding them and before adding more salt.

MSG, in the agency's words

MSG, monosodium glutamate, is the sodium salt of glutamic acid, sold as a white crystal and used like salt. It has a reputation that the agency's own position does not support. FDA's position, from the same page:

  • "FDA considers the addition of MSG to foods to be generally recognized as safe." Generally recognized as safe (GRAS) is the name of the FDA category the page places MSG in.
  • The glutamate released when the body digests protein "is chemically the same as the glutamate in MSG."
  • An average adult eats about 13 grams of glutamate a day from the protein in ordinary food, far more than added MSG contributes.
  • Glutamate has nothing to do with gluten.
  • Added MSG must be listed in the ingredient list as monosodium glutamate. Free glutamate in ingredients such as yeast extract or soy extracts is not labeled as MSG.

Whether to use MSG is a Preference. If a household member reports reacting to it, that is a question for a clinician, not for this manual.

Go deeper

What the savory pantry ingredients have in common

Every ingredient on FDA's list is either a protein that has been broken down (yeast extract, hydrolyzed vegetable protein, soy extracts) or a food in which protein breaks down as it ripens or ages (tomatoes, cheeses). That is the link: free glutamate. A cook does not need the chemistry to use them, only the habit of reaching for one of them when a seasoned dish still tastes hollow, and of tasting for salt afterward, because several of them are salty in their own right.

Sodium as a number

Sodium is the part of salt that the federal limits count. Salt is about 40 percent sodium, so each gram of salt you add carries about 400 mg of sodium (Harvard's Nutrition Source). Physical principle The figures below are published ones, stated as their publishers state them.

The published limits

The current edition of the Dietary Guidelines says the general population, ages 14 and above, should consume less than 2,300 mg of sodium a day, and gives lower limits for younger children (Dietary Guidelines for Americans, 2025-2030). FDA's Daily Value, the reference amount behind the percentages on a Nutrition Facts label, is the same: less than 2,300 mg a day, which FDA says is about 1 teaspoon of table salt (FDA, Sodium in Your Diet). The table shows the limits and what one serving carrying 500 mg of sodium from added salt would be against each. The 500 mg is our example, about 1.25 g of salt.

AgePublished limit, mg a dayA 500 mg serving as a share
1 to 3less than 1,200about 42 percent
4 to 8less than 1,500about 33 percent
9 to 13less than 1,800about 28 percent
14 and upless than 2,300about 22 percent

Limits from the Dietary Guidelines for Americans, 2025-2030. The share column is our arithmetic.

Where the sodium actually comes from

FDA puts average US intake at about 3,400 mg a day, and says that over 70 percent of dietary sodium comes from eating packaged and prepared foods. That is the honest consequence for a cook. The salt you weigh into a pot is the part of the total you can see and count; the larger part arrives already in the food. A household that cooks from raw ingredients controls more of its sodium than one that does not, because it decides the amount. That is a statement about who controls the number, not a health claim.

The salt calculator has a sodium box: type the grams of salt you added and the number of servings, choose who is eating, and it gives the sodium per serving from that salt and its share of the published limit for that age. It prints, every time, that it knows only the salt you added. Stock, canned beans, cheese, soy sauce, bread and sauces all carry sodium; their Nutrition Facts labels give the amount per serving, and you add those figures yourself.

Limits

This section reports the published sodium and saturated fat figures and does arithmetic on the salt you type in. It gives no dietary advice. It does not tell anyone to eat less salt, does not design a low-sodium diet, and does not assess anyone's diet. If you have high blood pressure, kidney disease, a pregnancy, or a prescription that bears on sodium, the amount is a decision for your clinician, which is the same place the current Dietary Guidelines send anyone with a condition. The sodium box also cannot see anything that came out of a package.

Go deeper

Three sodium figures, and which body set each

Two bodies have published two different kinds of number, and a reader who meets them in different places can think they conflict.

FigureWhat it isWho set it, and where we read it
Less than 2,300 mg a day, ages 14 and upThe limit in the current federal Dietary GuidelinesHHS and USDA, Dietary Guidelines for Americans, 2025-2030
Less than 2,300 mg a dayThe Daily Value on food labelsFDA, Sodium in Your Diet
2,300 mg a dayThe Chronic Disease Risk Reduction intake, a maximumThe national academies, as reported by Harvard's Nutrition Source
1,500 mg a day, ages 14 and upThe Adequate IntakeThe national academies, as reported by Harvard's Nutrition Source

The 2,300 mg figures are limits. The 1,500 mg figure is a different kind of number, an adequate intake, and the federal edition does not mention it. We state both and do not choose between them; which applies to a person is not a cooking question. Harvard's page adds that the body needs about 500 mg a day for its vital functions, and that historic intakes have ranged from about 200 mg a day to over 10,000. The current edition also says that "highly active individuals may benefit from increased sodium intake" to offset sweat losses, which is one more reason a single number does not settle any one person's case.

Added sugars in savory cooking

The current edition also sets a figure for added sugars, and it reaches savory cooking more than people expect. It says no amount of added sugars is recommended, and that one meal should contain no more than 10 grams of added sugars. Sugar is an ingredient in many savory sauces and glazes: ketchup, barbecue sauce, teriyaki, sweet chili sauce, and many bottled marinades. If a dish tastes too sharp, a pinch of sugar is one fix cooks reach for, and acid or fat is another. The ingredient list on a bottle names the added sugars; the Nutrition Facts label gives the grams.

Herbs and spices

The current federal edition says twice, once of meat and once of vegetables and fruits, "If preferred, flavor with salt, spices, and herbs" (Dietary Guidelines for Americans, 2025-2030). That line is this manual's warrant for teaching seasoning as a skill rather than as something to cut back.

Herbs are the leaves of plants, used fresh or dried: parsley, cilantro, basil, thyme, oregano, rosemary, dill, mint. Spices are the other dried parts: seeds (cumin, coriander, mustard), bark (cinnamon), roots and rhizomes (ginger, turmeric), fruits and berries (pepper, chile, allspice). The line between them is a cook's convention and blurs at the edges; coriander seed and cilantro leaf come from the same plant. Convention

When to add them

WhatWhen we add itWhy
Dried spices, ground or wholeEarly, stirred into the hot fat for a minute before the liquid goes in, or into the liquidThey need time and heat to give up their flavor; a minute in fat is the common method
Dried herbsEarly or in the middle, in the liquidThey soften and release their flavor over time
Woody fresh herbs: thyme, rosemary, bayEarly, whole sprigs removed at the endThey stand up to long cooking
Tender fresh herbs: parsley, cilantro, basil, dill, mintAt the end, or on the plateTheir flavor fades with long heat

Our defaults. Convention Recipes and cuisines differ, and a recipe's own instruction governs.

Spices in fat burn quickly. Keep the heat at medium, stir, and add the liquid or the next ingredient as soon as they smell toasted. A burnt spice tastes bitter and no addition fixes it; start the spices again. Test it

Dried against fresh: add a little and taste

Every cook wants a ratio for swapping a dried herb for a fresh one. We looked for a published one from an extension service or an agency and did not find one. The pages that do publish ratios are spice sellers' pages, and they disagree with each other herb by herb. So we do not give a ratio. A spoonful of crumbled dried herb holds more leaf than a spoonful of chopped fresh herb, because the water has gone. So when you swap, start with less than the recipe gives, add it early enough to soften, and taste before adding more. Test it Write what you used in the margin of the recipe, so the second time is a decision rather than a guess.

Spice blends and salt

Many blends, such as seasoned salt, some chili powders and some taco or poultry seasonings, contain salt. The ingredient list names it. If salt is in the blend, it counts in your seasoning: add the blend, taste, and only then decide on more salt. A blend with salt in it also carries sodium that the sodium box does not see unless you include it.

How long dried herbs and spices keep, and how to store them, is pantry management rather than seasoning; the pantry list says where that is covered.

See it: one recipe, two salts See it

Fictional example

Priya Raman and Tomas Esquivel are fictional, and every fact about them here is invented for this manual. They cook on a gas range, own a scale and a thermometer, and want the techniques nobody taught them. Tonight it is a pot of black beans from a recipe that says "2 teaspoons kosher salt" and names no brand. Their box is Diamond Crystal. Tomas remembers an older recipe from the same site tasting too salty.

Known: the recipe's wording; their salt is Diamond Crystal; their scale reads in 1 g steps. By Milk Street's weighing, 2 teaspoons of Diamond Crystal is about 6 g and 2 teaspoons of Morton coarse kosher about 10 g; by America's Test Kitchen's, about 5.6 g and 9.6 g.

Assumed (Priya's assumption): the recipe writer used Morton, because of the too-salty memory. If that is right, the recipe means about 10 g.

What they did: they followed the steps in Why a teaspoon is not a quantity and started at the lighter weight, 6 g, into the cooking liquid. At the end Tomas tasted: flat. He added salt 1 g at a time, tasting between, and stopped at 8 g total. Still heavy. A spoonful with two drops of lime was clearly better, so they added the juice of half a lime to the pot. They did not need fat.

The row in their tasting sheet: black beans; 8 g Diamond Crystal; half a lime; no fat; lime changed it most.

Open: which salt the recipe meant (the site's own about page or a note on the recipe settles it; they have not looked yet); whether 8 g is right for this pot next time, when the beans may be a different batch (their next row settles it); and how much sodium the canned tomatoes in the recipe added (the can's Nutrition Facts label settles it).

Fictional example

Walt Mbeki (fictional) is 71, cooks for himself and sometimes a neighbor, and keeps his sodium down by his own choice, not on anyone's instruction. He makes a saucepan of lentil soup that serves four, with 5 g of table salt weighed in, and uses the sodium box. The arithmetic: 5 g at 40 percent is about 2,000 mg, or about 500 mg a serving from the salt he added, which is about 22 percent of the 2,300 mg published limit for his age band. What the box cannot see: the carton of stock he used. Its Nutrition Facts label gives sodium per cup, and he adds that figure himself. Open: whether that total suits him is not a cooking question, and the manual does not answer it; Walt settles it with his own clinician if he wants a number for himself.

Practice: the three-cup test Practice

Minimum: one dish tasted in order, salt added in measured steps with the brand written down, and one row in the tasting sheet. Time: about 30 minutes beside cooking you were doing anyway. Materials: a pot of something soupy or saucy (beans, soup, a tomato sauce), your salt, a lemon or any vinegar, butter or olive oil, three small cups or bowls, clean spoons, a scale or measuring spoons, and the tasting sheet.

  1. Cook the dish with only the salt the recipe puts in early. If the recipe gives salt by volume with no brand, start at the lighter weight (the steps for an unnamed salt). Write the amount and brand.
  2. Taste it plain and give it one word. Flat, heavy, sharp or thin.
  3. Ladle three small cups. Into the first, a small pinch of salt. Into the second, two drops of acid. Into the third, a small dab of butter or a few drops of oil. Stir each.
  4. Taste across the three and the pot. Pick the one that improved most. If two did, note both.
  5. Season the pot with the winner, in steps. Salt in steps of about 1 g, acid a few drops at a time, fat a teaspoon at a time, tasting between.
  6. Write the row. Dish, total salt in grams or spoons with the brand, acid added, fat added, and which one fixed it.
Go deeper

Weigh your own teaspoon. If you have a scale, level a teaspoon of your salt onto it five times, write each reading, and compare the average with the published figure for your brand. Then try a heaped spoon. You will see how much the scoop changes the weight, which is the case for weighing. Test it

Salt early against salt late. Take two pieces of the same food, such as two chicken thighs or two slices of eggplant. Salt one by weight an hour ahead and keep it in the refrigerator; salt the other with the same weight just before cooking. Dry both, cook them side by side, and taste the centers. Write what you notice in the cook log.

Run the sodium box on a dish you cook often. Enter the salt you added, the servings, and the youngest eater's age band, then add the sodium from any packaged ingredient's label by hand.

Your household Your household

Check your work Check your work

Criteria

  • Did you taste before adding anything, and give the taste a word?
  • Is every amount of salt in your notes either in grams or in spoons with the brand named?
  • Did you change one thing at a time, so you know which change worked?
  • Did you test acid on a spoonful before it went into the pot?
  • Does your tasting sheet name which of salt, acid or fat changed the dish most?
  • If you used the sodium box, did you add the sodium from packaged ingredients yourself, and read the result as arithmetic rather than advice?

Worked example

Checked against the criteria, Priya and Tomas's pot of beans passes. They tasted before adding, worked from the lighter salt when the brand was unknown, added salt in 1 g steps, tested lime on a spoonful before the pot, and their row names the brand, the grams and the fix. One criterion is half met: they know the sodium from the salt they added, but not yet the sodium from the canned tomatoes. Under Priya's assumption that the recipe meant Morton, it intended about 10 g, and their pot was at its best at 8 g plus lime. If the recipe meant Diamond Crystal, it intended about 6 g and they went 2 g past it. The publisher's note settles which; either way, their row records what this pot needed.

Common mistakes

  • Adding salt and acid together. The dish improves and you do not know why. Change one thing per taste.
  • Following "kosher salt" without a brand. A factor of nearly two hides in that phrase. Start light and taste.
  • Seasoning a liquid fully before it reduces. Salt stays when water leaves. Season the reduced sauce, not the raw stock.
  • Treating the sodium box as a total. It knows only the salt you weighed. Labels carry the rest.
  • Burning spices in fat. Medium heat, stir, and move on as soon as they smell toasted.
  • Skipping the row. Without the tasting sheet, next time starts from the recipe again instead of from what you learned.

What is still unresolved

This chapter cannot know how salty your household likes its food; your tasting sheet settles that over a few weeks. It cannot see the sodium in packaged ingredients; their labels do. It does not decide how much sodium is right for any person; that is a clinician's decision, and Building a plate draws the same line for the rest of the federal figures. When the fault in a dish is not seasoning but undercooking, overcooking or the wrong method, When it goes wrong takes over.

Knowledge check and scenario

A recipe says "1 teaspoon kosher salt". Why is that not enough information?
Kosher salt brands differ in weight per spoon. By Milk Street's weighing, a teaspoon of Diamond Crystal is about 3 g and a teaspoon of Morton coarse kosher about 5 g. Without the brand, the amount could differ by about two thirds. Find the publisher's note, or start at the lighter weight and taste.
A stock tasted right when you started it. After an hour uncovered it tastes too salty. You added nothing. What happened?
Water evaporated and the salt stayed, so the concentration rose. Salt does not boil off. Season a liquid lightly at the start and finish seasoning after it has reduced.
A dish is salted and still tastes heavy and a little too sweet. What do you try first, and how?
Acid. Put one or two drops of vinegar or lemon on a spoonful, taste it against a plain spoonful, and add acid to the pot a little at a time only if the test spoonful was better.
You add 5 g of table salt to a pot that serves four. About how much sodium is in each serving from that salt?
Salt is about 40 percent sodium, so 5 g carries about 2,000 mg, or about 500 mg a serving. That is the salt you added only; packaged ingredients add more, and their labels give the amounts.
(Go deeper) Two test kitchens publish 3 g and 2.8 g for a teaspoon of the same kosher salt. Should you average them?
No. Both are measurements by named kitchens, and the difference, about 7 percent, is small next to the factor of about two between brands. Name the brand, weigh in grams, and say which kitchen's figure you used.
A recipe from a test kitchen whose house salt is Diamond Crystal calls for "1 tablespoon kosher salt" in a braise. Your box is Morton coarse kosher. What do you measure?
A tablespoon of Morton coarse kosher weighs about 15 g by Milk Street's figures; the recipe meant a tablespoon of Diamond Crystal, about 9 g. You would add about two thirds more salt than intended, and a braise reduces, which concentrates it further.
The recipe meant about 9 g. Converted by weight, that is about 1 3/4 teaspoons of Morton (9 divided by 5 g per teaspoon). Because a braise reduces, taste at the end before adding any more.
Salt at the table seasons the surface. Salt in the braising liquid seasons the meat and vegetables as they cook. It is a choice you can make, and it gives a different dish; a little salt in the pot plus a check at the end is the usual path.

Checklist

Records your learning only; it is not a qualification.