What heat does: the two families of method, browning, and why water will not go above boiling
Every cooking method sorted into dry heat or moist heat by what it does, browning understood as a reaction rather than a seal, and the two levers that are not the dial: the pan's surface and the lid.
- Start here: the essentials
- Two families of method
- Browning, and what stops it
- The ceiling: water stops at its boiling point
- The levers that are not the dial
- Carryover: cooking after the heat is off
- Fat, smoke and flavor
- See it: Priya and Tomas, and Walt
- Practice: one vegetable, two ways
- Your household
- Check your work
- Knowledge check and scenario
Start here Essentials
For a first pass, this chapter asks you to taste the difference between the two families of method once, and to name the family of what you cook next.
- Cook half of one vegetable in boiling water and half in a hot pan with a little fat, then taste them side by side (two families of method).
- Put the methods table beside the dish you were going to cook tonight and name its family: dry heat, moist heat, or both (two families).
- Dry the next thing you mean to brown with a towel before it touches the pan, and give each piece room (what stops browning).
Minimum time: about 25 minutes, once. Done when: you can say out loud which family the dish you are cooking tonight belongs to, and what would stop it browning.
Two families of method Understand
There are few cooking methods and very many dishes. A cook who knows the method a recipe uses can cook a different food the same way, fix the recipe when it does not work on their stove, and cook without one. This is the idea that makes the rest of the manual transferable.
The definitions here come from a federal dataset rather than a cookbook. USDA's Table of Cooking Yields for Meat and Poultry (Release 2, 2014) includes a glossary of cooking methods, written so that its laboratories cook food the same way each time. It divides methods by one question: is there liquid? Dry heat is "any cooking procedure that does not include the use of a liquid", such as baking, roasting and broiling. Moist heat is "any cooking procedure that involves the use of liquid". Convention Culinary curricula teach the same division. Rouxbe's home-cook syllabus is organized as dry-heat units and moist-heat units, and the Escoffier school's cooking-methods week sets out dry heat, moist heat and a third family, combination cooking, with braising as its example.
Dry heat
In dry heat, the food's surface meets hot air, hot metal or hot fat, all of which can be far hotter than boiling water. That is why dry heat can brown. USDA's glossary defines the dry methods this manual uses:
- Baked or roasted: cooked in an oven, surrounded by dry heat. The oven tray.
- Broiled or grilled: cooked directly under or above the heat source.
- Pan-broiled: cooked in an uncovered skillet over direct heat with little or no fat, the drippings poured off as they form.
- Pan-browned: cooked in an uncovered skillet over direct heat to get a brown surface.
- Pan-fried, sauteed or stir-fried: cooked in fat that does not cover the food. Sauteing is often thought of as using less fat and going faster than pan-frying. Stir-frying is cooking small pieces quickly in a large pan with a minimum of fat over very high heat "while constantly stirring". The fast skillet.
USDA also defines frying in deep fat, food immersed in fat deep enough to cover it, at an average fat temperature of 375 degrees F (190 C). This manual does not teach it (fire: the lid within reach says why).
Moist heat
In moist heat, the food sits in water or steam, and its surface can get no hotter than the water around it. That makes moist heat gentle and even, and it does not brown. USDA defines:
- Poached, simmered or stewed: cooked in liquid at a temperature low enough that "tiny bubbles just begin to break the surface", about 185 degrees F (85 C). Stewing is simmering for a long time in a tightly covered pot.
- Boiled is the same, in water at a full boil. Steaming, which the curricula list with it, cooks food over boiling water rather than in it.
Pasta, grains, beans and soups are moist heat. So is a vegetable boiled or steamed. The one pot is built on this family.
Both: the braise
USDA defines braised as food cooked on top of the range or in the oven, tightly covered, in a small amount of liquid at low heat for a long time. In practice a braise usually starts in dry heat, browning the meat and vegetables in fat, and finishes in moist heat with the liquid added and the lid on. That is why the Escoffier school files it as a third family. Convention This manual names it "both", and the braise teaches it.
| Method | Family | What the surface meets | Browns? | Where in this manual |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Roast or bake | Dry | Hot air | Yes | The oven tray |
| Broil or grill | Dry | Direct radiant heat | Yes | The oven tray |
| Saute, pan-fry, stir-fry | Dry | Hot metal and a little fat | Yes | The fast skillet |
| Simmer, poach, stew | Moist | Water at about 185 F | No | The one pot |
| Boil | Moist | Water at its boiling point | No | The one pot, Vegetables every day |
| Steam | Moist | Steam at the boiling point | No | Vegetables every day |
| Braise | Both | Hot fat, then liquid | The first stage | The braise |
The methods table lists every method with its definition and its family. To name the family of a dish, ask what the surface of the food meets while it cooks.
The federal names beside the curricula's
The curricula use more names than USDA's glossary, and each maps onto it. Rouxbe teaches sweating, cooking vegetables gently in a little fat until soft without browning them: dry heat held low enough that the vegetables' own water keeps the surface from browning. Rouxbe's submersion methods are USDA's poached, simmered and boiled. The Escoffier school's dry-heat list adds confit, food cooked slowly in fat; it is a low-temperature method and this manual does not teach it. USDA's pan-broiled and pan-browned are what most recipes call searing: little or no fat, an uncovered pan, a brown surface as the goal.
Two families or three
USDA's glossary defines braising on its own line and does not assign it a family. The Escoffier curriculum makes combination cooking a third family. The case for three is that a braise needs both skills in sequence: if the first stage does not brown, the second cannot fix it, because moist heat does not brown. The case for two is that every moment of a braise is in one family or the other, and naming which one tells you what the food is doing. This manual uses two families and calls braising "both", which keeps the question the same at every moment: what is the surface meeting now?
Browning, and what stops it
Browning is the main thing dry heat does that moist heat does not, and most of the flavor of roasted, seared and sauteed food comes from it. Its usual name is the Maillard reaction. A 2016 review in the National Library of Medicine's PubMed Central defines it as a chemical reaction between amino acids and reducing sugars at high temperature, "often called nonenzymatic browning reaction since it takes place in the absence of enzyme" (the review on Maillard reaction products). Amino acids are the building blocks of protein. Reducing sugars are sugars, such as glucose, with a chemical group that lets them take part in this reaction. The reaction produces both brown color and new flavors, and, in the review's account, it runs further the longer and the hotter food cooks. Physical principle
Caramelization is a different reaction: the browning of sugars on their own, without amino acids, when they are heated. The Escoffier school lists it as one of the effects of heat. Both reactions can run in a food that has sugars and protein, such as an onion cooked slowly until brown.
Browning is not a seal
"Sear the meat to seal in the juices" is one of the most repeated lines in cooking, and it is not what browning does. Browning is a reaction that makes color and flavor; nothing in it forms a barrier. A seared piece of meat keeps losing water while it cooks, which is what the sizzle is. Physical principle What keeps more juice in a cut of meat is resting it after cooking. The thermometer maker ThermoWorks explains that resting lets the protein fibers reabsorb moisture that would otherwise run out when the meat is cut (ThermoWorks on resting). Sear for flavor. Rest for juice. Carryover covers what resting also does to the temperature.
No onset temperature
This manual gives no temperature at which browning starts. The review we cite gives none, and the figure that circulates online was found only on a practitioner's site, with no food-science publisher behind it. The teaching here does not need one. What matters in a kitchen is the next section: whether the surface of the food can get hotter than boiling water, and what stops it.
This chapter explains what each method does to food. It does not say which method is healthiest, and it gives no diet advice. Two agencies have written something down where cooking method and health meet, and we state both as they do and make no further claim. The current Dietary Guidelines say to swap deep-fried cooking methods for baked, broiled, roasted, stir-fried or grilled ones. FDA's page on acrylamide, a substance that forms in some plant foods cooked at high temperature, is summarized below. Any question about what you should eat is for a clinician.
What FDA says about browning potatoes and toast
FDA explains that acrylamide forms from sugars and an amino acid, asparagine, in plant foods during high-temperature cooking "such as frying, roasting, and baking", and not in raw food or in food that is steamed or boiled. "More acrylamide accumulates when cooking is done for longer periods or at higher temperatures", and brown areas tend to contain more. For potatoes, frying forms the most, then roasting pieces, then baking whole; boiling, and microwaving whole potatoes with the skin on, form none. Soaking raw potato slices for 15 to 30 minutes before frying or roasting reduces it; drain and blot them dry, FDA adds, to prevent splattering or fires. Storing potatoes in the refrigerator raises it, so FDA says to keep them somewhere dark and cool instead. FDA suggests toasting bread to light brown rather than dark brown. In laboratory studies acrylamide caused cancer in animals, at levels much higher than those in food, and FDA says it is waiting for new research before considering new advice (FDA on acrylamide and food preparation). Ask the authority
What stops browning: water
While water sits on the surface of a food, that surface stays close to the boiling point of water. The heat arriving from the pan goes into turning the water into steam rather than into raising the temperature further. Only when the surface water has gone does the surface climb toward the temperature of the pan, and browning there speeds up. Physical principle Browning at the boiling point is slow, which is why a simmered stew does not brown in an afternoon and a dry skillet browns a steak in minutes.
So the question "why is this not browning?" is usually "where is the water coming from?"
| Where the water comes from | What to do |
|---|---|
| The food went in wet: rinsed produce, a marinade, ice from the freezer | Pat it dry with a towel before it goes in. Do not rinse raw meat; FSIS does not recommend it (raw meat) |
| The pieces are touching, so the steam each one gives off is trapped between them | Give each piece room; cook in batches (the levers) |
| The food released juice and it pooled in a crowded pan | Fewer pieces; a wider pan; let the liquid boil off before expecting color |
| The lid is on, so steam condenses and drips back | Lid off for anything you want brown |
| The pan was not hot when the food went in | Preheat the pan until the fat moves easily and shimmers |
| The food is moved before its surface has dried and browned | Leave it in place until it releases |
The point of the whole section is short: a wet pan is a pan at the boiling point of water, and a browning pan is not. When it goes wrong uses this to diagnose a pale dinner.
The ceiling: water stops at its boiling point
Liquid water at normal pressure cannot get hotter than its boiling point. FSIS's page on high altitude cooking puts it plainly: "water cannot exceed its own boiling point", no matter how high the cooking temperature (FSIS on high altitude cooking). Turning up the burner under a pot that is already boiling does not make the water hotter. It makes the water boil away faster. Physical principle
At sea level, water boils at 212 degrees F (100 C). That is the ceiling on every moist-heat method, and it explains three things a cook meets every week.
- A hard boil and a gentle one cook at nearly the same temperature. The difference is how much the water churns and how fast it evaporates. For beans and stews, a gentle simmer cooks just as well and breaks the food up less.
- A covered pot comes to a boil sooner. The lid keeps in heat that would otherwise leave with the steam.
- A wet pan cannot brown fast. The water in it, and on the food, holds the surface near the ceiling until it is gone (what stops browning).
Altitude lowers the ceiling
Air presses less on water at altitude, so water boils at a lower temperature. FSIS gives the air pressure as 14.7 pounds per square inch at sea level, 12.3 at 5,000 feet and 10.2 at 10,000 feet, a decrease of about 1/2 pound per 1,000 feet, and says that "with each 500-feet increase in elevation, the boiling point of water is lowered by just under 1 degree F."
| Elevation | Water boils at about | Where the figure comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Sea level | 212 F (100 C) | FSIS |
| 2,000 feet | 208 F (98 C) | FSIS |
| 5,000 feet | 203 F (95 C) | Our arithmetic on FSIS's rule (10 steps of just under 1 degree) |
| 7,500 feet | 198 F (92 C) | FSIS |
The consequences are FSIS's. Moist-heat cooking "may take up to one-fourth more cooking time" at 5,000 feet, depending on the density and size of the food. Turning the heat up does not help, because the water still cannot exceed its boiling point; it only boils off sooner and the food dries out. Above 2,500 feet the air is much drier and moisture evaporates faster, so covering food helps. And the oven is not affected: FSIS says to use the sea-level time and temperature guidelines when oven-roasting meat and poultry, because oven temperatures do not change with altitude. Altitude is a moist-heat problem. The altitude calculator gives your boiling point, and altitude covers adapting a recipe.
A pressure cooker works by the same rule turned around: sealed, it raises the pressure, and so the boiling point. This manual does not teach pressure cooking; follow the appliance maker's manual. Product-specific
The levers that are not the dial
The burner dial is one way to change what heat does to food. Four others matter as much, and on a slow electric coil or a weak hot plate they matter more, because they act at once while the dial takes minutes. Physical principle
| Lever | Toward browning | Toward gentle, even cooking |
|---|---|---|
| Surface area and crowding | Fewer pieces, spaced apart, in a wide pan | A full pan, pieces touching |
| The lid | Off, so steam escapes | On, so steam stays and condenses |
| The fat | A thin, even film in a hot pan | Little or none, or liquid instead |
| The food's starting temperature | Not straight from the freezer; dry | Cold is fine; a thick piece starts more evenly if it is not frozen |
Surface area and crowding
Each piece of food in a hot pan gives off water as steam. Spaced apart, the steam escapes and the surfaces dry and brown. Touching, the steam is trapped between the pieces, the juices pool, and the pan simmers its contents instead. A pan filled with cold food also has its heat divided among more food, so its surface cools further and recovers more slowly. A wider pan gives more room and lets liquid evaporate faster, which is also how a sauce reduces. FSIS makes the same point about a fryer basket: overcrowding causes undercooking, uneven cooking and overflow. In a skillet or on a tray, this manual's convention is a gap between pieces, about a finger's width on a tray. Convention Crowding on the tray and dry and spaced apply it.
The lid
A lid changes the family. An uncovered skillet is a dry-heat tool. Put a lid on it and the steam the food gives off condenses on the lid and falls back, the air inside fills with steam, and the food cooks in moist heat at the boiling point. That is useful when you want it: to cook a thick piece through gently after browning it, to wilt greens, to steam vegetables in a little water. It is the opposite of what you want while browning. Physical principle On one burner, the lid is the fastest way to move a pan between the families. At altitude, FSIS's advice to cover food applies to moist cooking, because drier air takes the water away faster.
The fat
A pan's surface is not perfectly flat, and food does not touch all of it. A thin film of fat fills the gaps and carries heat evenly into the whole surface of the food, so it browns evenly rather than in spots. Fat in a pan can be far hotter than boiling water, which is why it is part of dry heat. Physical principle How hot a fat can go before it breaks down is the last section of this chapter.
The food's starting temperature
Cold food takes heat out of the pan when it goes in, and a thick, very cold piece can brown and overcook outside before its center catches up. Taking food out of the refrigerator while you prepare everything else (ready first) narrows the gap. The limit on that is FSIS's: perishable food stays out of refrigeration for no more than 2 hours, or 1 hour when it is above 90 degrees F (32 C). Frozen food can be cooked from frozen, FSIS says, and it takes longer. Ask the authority
The levers on each burner
On gas, the dial acts in seconds, so it is a usable lever in a stir-fry. On an electric coil or smooth top, the element holds heat after you turn it down, so crowding, the lid and lifting the pan off the burner act faster than the dial. On induction the pan responds quickly, and its thickness decides how evenly the heat spreads. On a hot plate of low output, the heat stored in a heavy, fully preheated pan does most of the browning, so the batches have to be small. The heat you have describes each burner.
Carryover: cooking after the heat is off
Food keeps cooking after it leaves the heat. When a piece of meat comes off the pan, its outside is hotter than its center, and heat keeps moving inward until the two even out. The center's temperature rises for a while after the food is off the heat. This is carryover. Physical principle
The figures are one thermometer maker's, ThermoWorks, which publishes the same ranges on its resting page and in its food temperature FAQ.
| Size of the food | Rise while it rests (ThermoWorks) |
|---|---|
| A small steak, an individually cooked piece of chicken, a hamburger | At least 3 to 4 degrees F |
| A larger roast or a turkey | As much as 10 to 15 degrees F, depending on conditions |
| Anything kept warm in a low oven or under a lamp | Larger than the same food resting on a board |
The larger the mass, the larger the rise. ThermoWorks' advice for doneness is to take the meat off the heat before it reaches the temperature you want it to finish at. Its FAQ adds that a large roast or turkey can vary by as much as 20 to 30 degrees F from one part to another, which is why where you put the probe matters as much as the number (where to probe). Product-specific
Carryover and the federal minimum
Carryover is a tool for doneness above the safe minimum, not a way to reach the minimum. FSIS's temperature chart says to cook food to its minimum internal temperature, measured with a food thermometer, "before removing food from the heat source". A chicken thigh is safe when it reads 165 degrees F (73.9 C) before it leaves the pan or the oven, not when it is expected to coast there on the plate. Ask the authority
FSIS's own rest is part of its rule for whole cuts. Beef, pork, veal and lamb steaks, chops and roasts go to 145 degrees F (62.8 C) and then rest for at least 3 minutes. That rest is counted in the agency's standard. It does not lower the reading the meat has to reach first.
So the rule in this manual is: read the minimum before the food leaves the heat; let carryover take it from there toward the doneness you prefer, if you prefer it higher; and rest meat so it holds its juice. The timing calculator estimates a pull temperature from ThermoWorks' ranges and does not pull below the federal minimum. Carryover and doneness uses this for each food, and the safe temperatures table lists the minimums.
Fat, smoke and flavor
Every fat has a temperature at which it starts to break down and give off visible smoke. That is its smoke point. ThermoWorks' explanation of smoke points gives three facts that decide how to use fat in a pan (ThermoWorks on oil smoke points). Physical principle
- Smoke point falls as free fatty acid content rises. Free fatty acids are fatty acids not bound into the fat's molecules; refining removes many of them. So a refined oil smokes at a higher temperature than an unrefined oil from the same seed, and extra virgin olive oil sits below light olive oil.
- Flavor burns before smoke. In an unrefined oil, the compounds that carry its flavor "burn at temperatures below the smoke point of the oil itself", causing bad flavors before the oil starts to smoke.
- Breakdown speeds up near the smoke point. An oil that is smoking hard is past the point to cook in. Turn the heat down, and if it keeps smoking, take the pan off the burner (fire: the lid within reach).
Use smoke points for ordering, not as thresholds. No standards body publishes a smoke-point table. ThermoWorks' chart is one company's compilation, and the charts that circulate disagree with each other by tens of degrees for the same oil; many name no publisher. A home cook also has no reading of the pan's surface temperature to compare a smoke point with. What the order tells you is useful: for the hottest jobs, a sear or a stir-fry, a refined oil from the upper part of the chart; for gentler cooking and for flavor, an unrefined oil or butter, at lower heat. Convention
The common rule against cooking with olive oil does not follow from the chart. ThermoWorks puts extra virgin olive oil at 374 degrees F (190 C), lower than refined oils and higher than butter at 302 degrees F (150 C). That supports keeping it off the very highest heat, not keeping it out of the pan.
The current Dietary Guidelines say to "prioritize oils with essential fatty acids, such as olive oil", and that other options can include butter or beef tallow. We state it as the edition does and add nothing to it. Which fat suits which dish, by flavor, is in Salt, fat and acid and which fat.
One maker's smoke-point chart
The chart as ThermoWorks publishes it, in degrees F, with Celsius converted by us. It is one company's compilation; other published charts give different figures for the same oils, and none is from a standards body. Read it top to bottom as an order, not as a set of exact temperatures.
| Fat | Smoke point (ThermoWorks) |
|---|---|
| Avocado oil, refined | 520 F (271 C) |
| Clarified butter | 482 F (250 C) |
| Beef tallow | 480 F (249 C) |
| Peanut oil, refined; safflower; soybean; rice bran | 450 F (232 C) |
| Olive oil, light | About 450 F (232 C) |
| Cottonseed oil | 428 to 446 F (220 to 230 C) |
| Canola oil | 435 F (224 C) |
| Grapeseed oil | 421 F (216 C) |
| Corn oil; sunflower oil | 410 F (210 C) |
| Olive oil, extra virgin; lard | 374 F (190 C) |
| Coconut oil, unrefined; sesame oil, unrefined | 350 F (177 C) |
| Peanut oil, unrefined | 320 F (160 C) |
| Butter | 302 F (150 C) |
| Sunflower oil, unrefined | 225 F (107 C) |
Why the charts disagree
A smoke point is not a fixed property of "olive oil" or "canola oil". It depends on the free fatty acid content of the particular oil, which varies with refining, with the batch and with age, and on how the test is run. Charts compiled from different sources at different times give different numbers, and copies of copies lose their sources. Dozens of near-identical charts on sites with no named publisher were found while this chapter was researched; none is cited. One named publisher's chart, used for order, is the most this manual can stand behind.
See it: Priya and Tomas, and Walt See it
Priya Raman and Tomas Esquivel are fictional, and every fact about them here is invented for this manual. They cook most nights on a gas range at 900 feet, with a cast iron skillet, a stainless skillet, a Dutch oven, two sheet pans, a thermometer and a scale. They do not eat pork. Tonight is eight bone-in chicken thighs, browned and then braised with onions and stock.
The first attempt (Tomas). He takes the thighs from the package, wet, and puts all eight in the cast iron skillet at once. After 6 minutes they are pale and sitting in liquid. Known: the pan was full, the thighs were wet, the lid was off. The reading: two sources of water at once, the wet surface and the juice pooling between crowded pieces. The pan was cooking in moist heat at the ceiling.
The second attempt (Priya). She pats the thighs dry with paper towels and browns them four at a time, skin side down, a gap between each, lid off, leaving them in place until they release. They brown. Then all eight go into the Dutch oven with the onions and stock, lid on, and the dish moves into moist heat on purpose. The family: both. Browning first, then a braise.
The disagreement. Tomas suggests taking the thighs out at 160 degrees F and letting carryover bring them to 165. Priya reads FSIS's chart: the minimum is read before the food leaves the heat. They leave the pot on until the thickest thigh reads 165 degrees F, then rest the thighs.
Assumed (theirs): at 900 feet, by FSIS's rule, their water boils at about 210 degrees F (212 minus just under 1.8), close enough to sea level that the braise times in their recipe need no change. Open: whether they prefer the thighs taken higher than 165 for texture, which FSIS allows "for reasons of personal preference". That is settled by tasting and a line in the cook log, not by this chapter.
Walt Mbeki (fictional) cooks at 6,200 feet on a two-burner hot plate. A pot of soaked beans that his recipe says will be tender in an hour is still firm at an hour.
Known: his elevation and the recipe's time. The arithmetic: by FSIS's rule of just under 1 degree F per 500 feet, his water boils at about 200 degrees F, about 12 degrees below the sea-level boil the recipe was written at. What does not help: turning the hot plate up, which would boil the water away faster and leave the beans the same. What does: time, and the lid, since FSIS says covering food helps above 2,500 feet. Assumed (his): that the beans will take longer by something like FSIS's "up to one-fourth more" figure. That figure is for 5,000 feet, and FSIS gives none for 6,200. Open: how much longer his beans take, which his own cook log settles after two or three pots.
- USDA, Table of Cooking Yields, Release 2: the glossary of cooking methods this chapter's definitions come from.
- Review of Maillard reaction products (PubMed Central): the definition of browning as a reaction.
- FSIS, high altitude cooking: the boiling-point rule and why altitude is a moist-heat problem.
- ThermoWorks, resting: one maker's carryover figures and why resting keeps juice.
Practice: one vegetable, two ways Practice
Minimum: cook half of one vegetable in boiling water and half in a hot pan with a little fat, taste them side by side, and name the family of each. Time: about 25 minutes. Materials: one vegetable that takes both methods (two zucchini, a head of broccoli, a few carrots), a pot, a skillet, oil, salt, a clean towel, two plates, the cook log.
- Cut the vegetable into even pieces (four cuts), and split it into two piles.
- Boil the first pile in salted water until a piece is tender when you bite it. Drain it onto a plate.
- Dry the second pile with a towel. Heat the skillet with a thin film of oil until the oil moves easily and shimmers.
- Brown the second pile in one layer with space between the pieces, lid off. Leave the pieces in place for a couple of minutes before turning them, until they have color.
- Taste both, side by side. Write in the cook log which was which family, and what differed in color, texture and flavor.
Crowd a third pile on purpose. Put a pile twice the size into the same skillet, straight from a rinse, with the lid on for the first 3 minutes. Compare it with the browned pile and write the cause in the cook log: water, crowding, the lid, or all three. Name a week of dinners. For each meal you cook this week, write its family in the cook log's dish column.
Your household Your household
Check your work Check your work
Criteria
- Can you name tonight's dish's family by what the surface of the food meets: hot air, metal or fat (dry), water or steam (moist), or one then the other (both)?
- Can you say what would stop it browning, and where the water would come from?
- Did the browned half of the vegetable go into the pan dry, in one layer, with space, lid off?
- Do you read a safe minimum before food leaves the heat, and treat carryover as something that happens after it?
- Do you treat a smoke-point chart as an order of fats, not as exact temperatures?
Worked example
Priya and Tomas's second attempt passes. They named the dish as both families, said the first attempt failed to brown because of water from two sources, and fixed both. They read 165 degrees F in the thickest thigh before the pot came off the heat. Their first attempt fails the third criterion, and the cook log line, "crowded and wet: pale; dried and in two batches: brown", is the record of why.
Common mistakes
- Turning up the heat under a pot that is already boiling. The water does not get hotter; it boils away.
- Searing "to seal in the juices". Browning is flavor. Resting keeps juice.
- Putting the lid on a pan of food you want brown. The lid makes it moist heat.
- Filling the pan to save a batch. The crowded batch steams, and the time saved goes into a pale result.
- Pulling chicken early to let carryover reach the minimum. The minimum is read before it leaves the heat.
- Reading a smoke-point chart as a rule. Charts disagree by tens of degrees; use the order.
What is still unresolved
The temperature each food must reach is settled in Telling when food is done, and when it is safe. How long a particular dish takes at your altitude is settled by your cook log and the altitude calculator, which gives your boiling point but not your bean's cooking time. Whether a method suits your health is a question for a clinician, not for this manual.